Skip to main content

Ecommerce Payment KPIs: What to Measure and How to Improve Payment Performance

Published - 20 February 2025
Revised - 26 October 2026

Written or reviewed by Libby James, founder of Merchant Advice Service and specialist in merchant payments and complex provider requirements.

FREE • INDEPENDENT • NO OBLIGATION Need help finding the right payment provider?

Tell us about your business, current payment setup and what you're looking to change. We'll use it to understand your requirements before identifying providers that may be suitable.

General payment enquiry
20% complete
1 Business
2 Payments
3 Volumes
4 Requirements
5 Contact
01 · Your business

Tell us a little about your business

Just the basics to start. This should only take a few seconds.

Invalid Input
Optional — this can help us understand your business more quickly.
Invalid Input
Invalid Input
General payment enquiry
40% complete
✓ Business
2 Payments
3 Volumes
4 Requirements
5 Contact
02 · Your payments

How does your business take payments?

Choose the options that best describe your current payment setup.

💻 How do you take payments? *

Select all that apply.

How do you take payments?



Invalid Input

💳 Do you currently accept card payments? *

This helps us understand whether you're switching provider or setting up for the first time.

Do you currently accept card payments?
Invalid Input
If you use more than one provider, enter the main one.
Invalid Input
General payment enquiry
60% complete
✓ Business
✓ Payments
3 Volumes
4 Requirements
5 Contact
03 · Payment volumes

Tell us a little about your payment volumes

Estimates are absolutely fine. These details help narrow down providers that may fit your business.

💳 Approximately how much do you take in card payments each month? *

Choose the closest range.

Approximately how much do you take in card payments each month?





Invalid Input

🧾 What is your average transaction value? *

Choose the closest range.

What is your average transaction value?





Invalid Input

🌍 Where are your customers based? *

Select all that apply.

Where are your customers based?




Invalid Input

💰 Which currencies do you need to accept? *

Select all that apply.

Which currencies do you need to accept?



Invalid Input
General payment enquiry
80% complete
✓ Business
✓ Payments
✓ Volumes
4 Requirements
5 Contact
04 · What you need

What matters most in your next payment provider?

Tell us what you're trying to improve, change or achieve.

🎯 What do you need from a payment provider? *

Select all that apply.

What do you need from a payment provider?








Invalid Input

🔎 Why are you looking for a payment provider? *

Select all that apply.

Why are you looking for a payment provider?








Invalid Input
Optional - add any platforms, software or systems that are important to your setup.
Invalid Input
Optional - only add anything that may help us understand your payment setup.
Invalid Input
General payment enquiry
100% complete
✓ Business
✓ Payments
✓ Volumes
✓ Requirements
5 Contact
05 · Your contact details

Tell us how suitable providers can contact you

We'll review your answers and may share your enquiry with suitable payment providers. Where relevant, those providers can then contact you directly about your requirements.

✓
Free to use

No fee to submit an enquiry through Merchant Advice Service.

✓
Relevant provider introductions

We use your answers to identify payment providers that may be suitable for your requirements.

✓
Direct provider contact

If your enquiry is shared, partner providers may contact you directly to discuss your requirements.

Your contact details

Add your details so Merchant Advice Service and, where relevant, suitable partner providers can contact you about your enquiry.

Invalid Input
We’ll use this to contact you about your enquiry.
Invalid Input
We may use this if we need to clarify your requirements or discuss your enquiry.
Invalid Input
Free to use · No obligation · We will review your requirements and, where appropriate, share your enquiry with suitable payment providers who may contact you directly.

Quick Summary

Useful ecommerce payment KPIs go beyond sales volume: authorisation rate, checkout conversion, payment-method mix, chargebacks, refunds and effective processing cost show where payment performance is leaking. For ecommerce payment kpis, two apparently similar providers can produce very different outcomes once business model, payment channels and provider fit are compared. Where ecommerce payment kpis affects a commercial decision, Merchant Advice Service can help translate it into criteria around business model, payment channels and provider fit.

Ecommerce payment performance should be measured across the entire customer payment journey, not reduced to one success-rate figure. Successful authorisations are important, but checkout abandonment, authentication, fraud controls, recurring payment failures and the overall cost of collecting revenue all affect the outcome.

To identify where payments may be underperforming, analyse results by payment method, issuer, customer location, currency, device and provider. Two businesses with similar headline success rates can have very different underlying problems.

Merchant Advice Service is an independent UK payments information, comparison and provider-matching service. We help businesses understand how payment performance relates to gateway compatibility, acquiring, provider suitability and total commercial costs.

Comparing ecommerce payment providers? If you are deciding between payment processors, merchant accounts and gateways for an online business, explore our ecommerce provider comparison guide. We explain how to assess suitability, integrations, costs and payment requirements before choosing a provider.

What are ecommerce payment KPIs?

Ecommerce payment key performance indicators (KPIs) measure how effectively attempted purchases become successful, settled revenue, and what happens when a transaction fails or is reversed.

Useful measures cover payment acceptance, checkout conversion, authentication, declines, subscription recovery, fraud, refunds, settlement and processing costs.

The objective is not to fill a dashboard with figures. It is to locate commercially important problems and distinguish issues that a payment provider can influence from problems elsewhere in the customer journey.

The ecommerce payment KPIs worth tracking

KPIWhat it measuresHow to segment it
Payment success Completed payments compared with attempts Provider, method, market, device
Authorisation Approvals among card authorisation requests Issuer, card type, acquirer
Declines Failed card requests and their causes Decline reason, issuer, country
Checkout conversion Customers reaching payment who complete an order Device, browser, checkout
Authentication 3D Secure performance and abandonment Challenge, issuer, device
Subscription recovery Failed recurring payments recovered later Reason, retry, customer group
Disputes and refunds Reversed or challenged transactions Product, market, reason
Processing cost Cost of generating successful revenue Provider, method, currency
Settlement How reliably and quickly cleared funds arrive Acquirer, region, currency

1. Payment success rate

This measures completed payments as a proportion of attempts, using a consistent definition of both terms.

Formula: Successful payments ÷ payment attempts × 100.

Decide in advance whether repeat retries, authentication failures and fraud-blocked attempts count as distinct attempts. Changing the denominator between reports can make performance appear to improve or worsen when nothing material has changed.

2. Card authorisation rate

Authorisation rate reflects the proportion of card requests submitted for approval that issuers authorise.

Formula: Approved authorisations ÷ authorisation requests × 100.

Lower approval rates may indicate revenue being lost, but some declines are legitimate. Analyse failures by issuing bank, customer market, card category, transaction type and acquirer before drawing conclusions.

Improving approval rates should not come at the expense of fraud management.

Merchant Advice Service view

Aggregate authorisation rates can conceal performance differences across regions, devices and payment methods. We recommend identifying which segments are underperforming before deciding whether the acquiring arrangement or gateway needs changing.

3. Transaction decline rate

This shows how often attempted card payments are rejected or otherwise declined within the defined measurement scope.

Formula: Declined card requests ÷ relevant card requests × 100.

Distinguish issuer refusals, risk screening, authentication failures, incorrect payment details and technical errors.

Each requires a different response. An issuer's insufficient-funds decision is not fixed in the same way as a broken checkout integration.

4. Decline reasons

Track the mix of decline reasons in addition to the overall percentage.

For example, determine the share caused by inadequate funds, expired cards, failed authentication, suspected fraud, issuer restrictions and system errors.

Decline codes and provider reporting can help identify failures worth investigating. They may also show which errors need the customer to update details rather than triggering another attempt.

5. Checkout-to-paid conversion

Not every lost sale reaches card authorisation. Customers may exit the checkout because of delivery costs, unavailable payment methods, slow pages, confusing forms or authentication friction.

Formula: Successful paid orders ÷ customers reaching the payment stage × 100.

Analyse this by browser, device, checkout version and payment method. Do not assume all abandonment is attributable to the payment provider.

6. 3D Secure and authentication performance

For online card payments, monitor transactions entering authentication, successful and failed authentications, customer abandonment, challenged versus frictionless journeys and what happens to authorisation afterwards.

Strong Customer Authentication requirements apply to relevant electronic payments in the UK, subject to applicable rules and exemptions.

The objective is a secure and compliant experience without avoidable technical friction, not the removal of authentication controls.

7. Subscription payment failure rate

Subscription businesses should distinguish initial sign-up transactions from renewals.

Monitor first-payment success, renewal success, recoverable declines, hard failures, expired payment credentials and customers lost after unsuccessful collections.

One failed collection may later be recovered. Reporting only the initial failure rate can therefore overstate permanent revenue loss.

8. Failed-payment recovery rate

Formula: Recovered failed payments ÷ recoverable failed payments × 100.

Define carefully which failures qualify for recovery. Providers may support scheduled retries, credential updates and customer messaging, but hard declines should not be repeatedly resubmitted without regard to provider and scheme rules.

For further guidance, see our subscription payment processing guide.

9. Dispute and chargeback rate

Measure both the number and value of disputes relative to relevant processed transactions. Segment by country, product, payment method and dispute reason to identify the cause.

By count: Disputed transactions ÷ relevant transactions × 100.

By value: Disputed value ÷ relevant processed value × 100.

Fraud, unrecognised billing, delivery problems, subscription cancellations and refund disagreements can all contribute.

Check the monitoring requirements applicable to your card schemes and payment provider rather than relying on outdated universal thresholds.

10. Refund rate

Refunds and chargebacks should not be combined into one KPI.

Refunds may reflect ordinary returns, cancellations, fulfilment issues, duplicate charges or customer expectations rather than payment-provider shortcomings.

By count: Refunded orders ÷ paid orders × 100.

By value: Total refunded value ÷ successful paid value × 100.

Review seasonal effects, especially in travel, events and future-delivery sectors.

11. Cost per successful payment

Advertised transaction percentages rarely describe the complete cost of accepting payments.

Formula: Relevant total processing costs ÷ successful payments.

Include gateway, acquiring, authorisation, international, foreign exchange and fixed service charges where applicable.

A payment method with a higher visible fee can still deliver a better commercial outcome if it produces more successful revenue.

12. Effective payment cost rate

Higher-volume businesses may also compare their total payment costs with successfully processed value.

Formula: Relevant total processing costs ÷ successful payment value × 100.

This captures the combination of fixed and variable charges more effectively than a single quoted processing rate.

For a deeper explanation, see our guide to interchange fees and pricing models.

13. Settlement performance

An approved payment is not the same as cash arriving in the merchant's account.

Track expected and actual settlement times, delayed or held amounts, reserves and performance by currency or acquiring arrangement.

Settlement differences matter to businesses with substantial advertising, payroll, inventory or supplier commitments.

Investigate whether delays are contractual, underwriting-related or technical.

14. Payment-method performance

Compare cards, digital wallets, bank payments and relevant local payment methods against conversion, successful payment rate, cost, refund behaviour, dispute exposure and average order value.

Methods that work well for domestic customers may not deliver the same result internationally. Prioritise methods that match the people and markets the business actually serves.

15. International payment performance

International ecommerce businesses should examine card-issuer country, customer location, currency, provider, acquiring location and payment method separately.

A healthy overall authorisation rate can disguise persistent problems in one market.

Where performance varies materially, consider the roles of cross-border acquiring, local payment preferences, authentication requirements and issuer behaviour.

Our foreign-currency merchant account guide provides more detail on accepting payments across currencies.

16. Payment gateway availability and technical errors

Track platform downtime, gateway responses, API errors, checkout failures, latency and sudden shifts in payment acceptance.

An integration fault can resemble a customer or issuer problem unless the business monitors each stage of the payment flow.

Useful alerts include unusual declines, elevated error rates, payment-method outages and transaction-processing delays.

What is a good ecommerce payment success rate?

There is no universal target that fits every merchant. Transaction values, customer geography, issuer mix, card types, one-off versus subscription billing and fraud rules all influence the achievable result.

Start with reliable historical data and investigate meaningful changes.

Ask whether particular markets, devices or providers are declining, whether retry recovery is improving and whether a higher approval rate has created additional fraud or dispute exposure.

How should ecommerce payment KPIs be segmented?

Prioritise the dimensions most likely to explain commercial performance:

  • Provider and acquirer
  • Payment gateway
  • Payment method and card type
  • Issuer and customer countries
  • Currency
  • Device and browser
  • First-time and returning customers
  • Transaction value
  • Subscription versus one-off payments

Not every business needs all these reports immediately. Begin with the most significant revenue flows and add further detail where anomalies suggest it is useful.

How often should payment KPIs be reviewed?

  • As events happen: Major outages, elevated error rates and serious acceptance anomalies.
  • Daily or weekly: Authorisation, declines, authentication and method performance where volumes justify it.
  • Monthly: Costs, disputes, refunds, settlements and broad provider trends.
  • Quarterly: Whether the wider payment infrastructure still supports business needs.

The monitoring frequency should reflect transaction volume and the financial significance of a problem.

Common mistakes when measuring payment performance

Looking only at the overall success rate

An average may obscure poor performance for an important customer segment or payment method.

Counting retries inconsistently

Use the same definitions across reporting periods; otherwise retry behaviour can distort comparisons.

Assuming all declines are preventable

Some requests are correctly refused by the issuer or risk controls and should not simply be retried.

Optimising approvals without tracking fraud

An approval-rate gain is not necessarily beneficial if losses and disputes increase faster.

Using universal benchmarks

Two merchants with different transaction and customer mixes are unlikely to have identical appropriate targets.

Judging providers by headline fees alone

Compare real processing costs with collected revenue and technical capability, not only the advertised card rate.

When might payment KPIs indicate you should review your provider?

One disappointing week is not sufficient evidence that a provider needs replacing.

Repeated issues may warrant investigation if you see:

  • Poor acceptance in key markets
  • Missing payment methods
  • Limited subscription recovery
  • Recurring outages
  • Slow settlement
  • Insufficient reporting
  • Processing costs that no longer suit the business

Diagnose the underlying issue first. It may be related to the checkout, payment-method configuration, acquiring arrangement or provider policy rather than the provider's overall suitability.

For practical considerations, read our guide to switching merchant account provider.

Merchant Advice Service view: measure payments as revenue infrastructure

Payments are more than a cost line for growing ecommerce businesses.

The payment setup influences whether sales convert into collected revenue, how much collection costs and whether the business can expand.

  1. Can customers successfully complete payment?
  2. What does each successful payment actually cost?
  3. Will the current infrastructure support future requirements?

Merchant Advice Service can help businesses assess their payment requirements and identify potentially suitable providers.

Our independent information and provider-matching service is free to businesses, with no obligation to proceed.

Related ecommerce payment guides

About Merchant Advice Service

Founded in 2016, Merchant Advice Service helps UK businesses understand card-processing requirements and find payment providers that may suit their activities, integrations, customers and commercial needs.

We advise across merchant accounts, payment gateways, higher-risk businesses, international payments, recurring payments and specialist integrations.

MAS is not itself a bank, card acquirer or payment processor and cannot guarantee an account will be approved.

Our matching and introduction service is free to businesses. We may earn a commission or referral fee if a merchant proceeds with a commercial partner.

Learn more about how we research and compare providers.

Sources and further reading

Editorial and commercial disclosure

Merchant Advice Service publishes independent information about payment products, provider capabilities and commercial considerations.

Mentioning a company for educational or comparison purposes is not a guarantee that it is suitable for every business or that MAS can introduce merchants to that company.

MAS may receive referral income from some partners after a successful introduction. Providers are not paid participants in this article unless expressly identified as such.

Pricing, integration availability and underwriting criteria can change, so verify material details with each provider before proceeding.

FAQs

What are the most important ecommerce payment KPIs?
The most useful KPIs usually include payment success rate, card authorisation rate, decline rate and decline reasons, checkout-to-payment conversion, authentication performance, disputes, refunds, payment costs and settlement. Subscription businesses should also monitor failed-payment recovery.
What is the difference between payment success rate and authorisation rate?
Authorisation rate usually measures whether card authorisation requests sent to the card network are approved by issuers. Payment success rate can cover the wider payment journey and may include failures occurring before or after authorisation. Businesses should define the denominator consistently before comparing performance.
What is a good ecommerce payment success rate?
There is no universal percentage that is appropriate for every ecommerce business. Performance varies by geography, card mix, payment method, transaction type, fraud controls, authentication and acquiring setup. Establishing your own baseline and comparing relevant segments is usually more useful than relying on a generic benchmark.
Why do ecommerce payments get declined?
Payments can fail because of issuer declines, insufficient funds, incorrect payment information, authentication requirements, fraud controls, card restrictions or technical errors. Payment providers can return decline codes and other information that help merchants understand the cause.
How can I improve my ecommerce authorisation rate?
Start by analysing where and why payments are failing. Compare performance by issuer, customer country, card type, payment method and acquirer, and distinguish issuer declines from authentication, fraud-control and technical failures. Payment analytics platforms increasingly provide this segmentation.
Should I retry every declined payment?
No. Some failures can be retried, while others should not be repeatedly resubmitted. Payment providers can return decline or advice codes indicating different next steps, and card networks can limit retries.
What payment KPIs should a subscription business track?
Subscription businesses should monitor first-payment success, renewal success, failed renewals, decline reasons, recovered failed payments, payment-method updates and customers lost because payments could not be recovered. Automated retry systems can recover some failed subscription payments.
How does 3D Secure affect payment performance?
3D Secure can affect authentication, fraud management and successful completion of online card payments. Merchants should monitor authentication success, challenge/abandonment behaviour and subsequent authorisation rather than looking only at overall payment success. UK Strong Customer Authentication rules apply to relevant electronic payments subject to applicable exemptions.
How should I measure the cost of ecommerce payments?
Useful measures include cost per successful payment and payment costs as a percentage of successful payment value. Include relevant transaction, gateway, authorisation, international, FX and fixed service costs rather than comparing only advertised transaction rates.
When should I consider changing ecommerce payment provider?
A review may be worthwhile where the current provider repeatedly performs poorly in important markets, restricts required integrations or payment methods, provides insufficient reporting, has become commercially uncompetitive or no longer supports the way the business operates. A poor KPI by itself does not necessarily mean switching provider is the answer.
FREE • INDEPENDENT • NO OBLIGATION

Need help finding the right payment provider?

Tell us about your business, how you take payments and what you're looking to change. We'll use your answers to identify providers that may be suitable.

Find suitable payment providers
Libby James – Founder & Payments Expert
Written by Libby James

Libby James is the founder and Managing Director of Merchant Advice Service. Since 2016, she has worked directly with businesses and payment providers across merchant accounts, card processing, payment gateways and complex provider requirements.

Libby specialises in high-risk, declined and harder-to-place merchants, as well as businesses requiring specialist payment methods, integrations or international support. She writes and reviews Merchant Advice Service content, drawing on practical experience gained from real merchant enquiries and provider relationships.

Related Articles